Wednesday, January 1, 2020

Good Question, Wrong Motive


By:  Dale Weckbacher

Text:  Mark 12:13-17

Mark 12:13
 And they sent to him some of the Pharisees and some of the Herodians, to trap him in his talk.
(ESV)

Happy New Year everyone, or for those reading this that live in the United States, happy presidential election year.  Yes, it is another presidential election year in the U.S.  This means the inundation of the airwaves with continuous campaign ads that slam opponents and tout candidates as saviors that will save the world.  There will also be countless debates that are not true debates over issues important to a majority of voters but opportunities for candidates to make soundbites they will use in advertisements or something used by opponents to win the nomination in their party.  It is at these so-called debates that moderators and candidates ask questions that may appear good at first but have a political motive and agenda behind them. 

Mark 12:13-17 describes an encounter Jesus had with the Pharisees and Herodians.  The text begins with these people approaching Jesus with the purpose of trapping Him in His Words (Mark 12:13).  It is ironic that the very people given the responsibility to guard the Word of God are trying to trap the author of scripture in His words.  However, they do not believe Jesus is who He says He is, and have an agenda to publicly expose Jesus as a fraud using an issue impacting the lives of everyone, taxes,  They ask a good question about whether it is necessary to pay taxes to Caesar but they have the wrong motives for had Jesus answered with a simple yes or no, they would have used His answer against Him.  Had Jesus answered yes, they would have questioned why he condones paying taxes to sinful Romans and possibly even accused Jesus of colluding with them by dining with them (Matthew 9:10-11).  However, had Jesus answered with a no, they no doubt would have accused Jesus and his followers of planning to overthrow the Romans, leading to Jesus and his Disciples’ arrest and execution for treason.    

The question the Pharisees and Herodians ask Jesus is a gotcha question or a question designed to make someone give an answer that entraps them no matter how they answer it (Mark 12:14).  The answer to the question is a simple yes or no but Jesus, knowing the motive behind the question does not fall into the trap of giving a yes or no answer but instead answers the question with a question (Mark 12:15-16).  In essence, Jesus asks them a gotcha question revealing their real motive and exposing their history of robbing God (Malachi 3:8; Mark 12:17). 

Jesus as the Son of God and God Himself had a perfectly centered focus on His heavenly father and was not about to fall into the trap of those trying to entrap Him with a gotcha question.  However, we must maintain our godly focus so as not to fall into any traps due to gotcha questions or false teaching.  The extremes of doctrines of moralism or liberalistic theology prevalent in the Church today are false doctrines that lead to one potentially falling into a gotcha question trap.

1)      Moralism (Romans 12:2-3) – Once one makes a profession of faith in Jesus as his or her savior and receives justification and forgiveness of sins, they enter the sanctification process where they lose conformity to the world and its manner of thinking and are transformed (Romans 12:2).  Romans 12:3 however, is a warning against becoming overly moralistic as this transformation process occurs in our lives.  While this transformation is a miraculous process of the work of the Holy Spirit in a believer’s life, it does not cause God to love them more than he did when He justified them.  The greatest love anyone can have for another is to lay down his or her life for them (John 15:13), something Jesus demonstrated by laying down His life to rescue us from our sins (Romans 5:8).  One professing a Gospel of moralistic superiority runs the risk of falling into the trap of a gotcha question with the exposure of some sin in their lives. 
2)      Liberalistic theology (Ephesians 2:8; Romans 6:1-4) – However, while we receive justification and forgiveness of sin by the grace of God (Ephesians 2:8), we must not use God’s grace as an excuse to continue sinning.  This is the word of caution offered by Romans 6:1-2, for to continue sinning believing that our profession of faith provides blanket forgiveness of any sin we may want to commit is, in essence, using God.  Jesus did not die on the cross to provide an excuse to sin but to rescue people from the death penalty of sin (Romans 6:23).  Liberalistic theology tarnishes one’s witness for Christ because a non-believer sees no change in the life of someone professing Jesus as his or her savior and sees no reason to make such a profession of faith. 
3)      Balanced Gospel (Ephesians 2:8; Hebrews 5:12-13; Romans 12:1-2) – A balanced Gospel that does not fall into the trap of moralism or liberalistic theology presents the best defense against falling into the trap of a gotcha question.  A balanced approach to the Gospel understands that all have sinned and need a savior and that one only inherits eternal life through the grace of God and the love of Christ demonstrated on the cross (Romans 3:23; 5:8).  However, the calling of the Gospel also involves making disciples which requires one becoming a disciple themselves (Matthew 28:19-20).  Discipleship occurs through the worship of God and the study of the Word of God both personally and listening to the teaching of the Word in Church or a Bible study group.  However, as a disciple of Christ grows in his or her knowledge of the Word of God, they must guard against pride or thinking more highly of themselves as God brings transformation to his or her life (Romans 12:3).  A balanced approach to the Gospel allows one to react to a gotcha question by pointing the questioner to Christ and His Word, disarming the trap of the gotcha question.

My prayer for those reading this is that they have a happy and safe new year and that they would grow in the knowledge of the Word of God.  I also pray for wisdom to handle any gotcha questions and avoid falling into any traps by using the opportunity of engaging one asking a gotcha question by pointing them to Christ and the Word of God.  May God bless everyone reading this. 

No comments:

Post a Comment